What Do Financial Regulators Do?

Contents

Financial regulators are a part of to the global financial system, and they work to ensure that financial institutions and firms operate according to applicable laws and regulations. Examples of well-known financial regulators from around the world are the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the United Kingdom, Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC).

Scope

How Do Financial Regulators Protect Investors?

Fraud Prevention: Regulators can work to prevent financial fraud, such as Ponzi schemes, illegal insider trading, and unauthorized trading platforms. They may work closely with law enforcement to detect suspicious activity early and shut down fraudulent schemes.
Promoting Transparency: Financial regulators can mandate that companies disclose information about their financial performance, including revenue, expenses, debts, and other important data. This allows investors to make informed decisions. For example, companies listed on public exchanges must issue regular reports like quarterly earnings statements, which are crucial for evaluating their financial health.
Overseeing Consumer Protection: Many regulators enforce rules that ensure financial institutions treat consumers fairly. This includes protection from deceptive practices, ensuring clarity in contracts, and providing access to recourse in case of disputes. In some countries, regulatory bodies also offer compensation schemes for investors who lose money due to a firm’s misconduct or insolvency. For instance, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) in the UK protects investors if a regulated firm collapses.
Safeguarding Market Integrity: Regulators prevent market manipulation, ensuring that securities prices are determined by fair trading and real supply and demand. Without proper oversight, bad actors could manipulate prices for their gain, leaving regular investors at a loss.
Educating Investors: Many financial regulators take an active role in educating the public about their rights as investors and the risks associated with different financial products. They also issue warnings about potential scams and suspicious firms, helping to protect the public from fraudsters. Some financial regulators publish warning lists on their official site.
Licensing and similar: A financial regulator can require certain types of financial institutions, firms or individuals to be registered with them and have a valid license, authoritisation, or similar. Investors can contact the financial regulator to find out if a particular entity is registered with the regulator and if their authorization is current and valid. Nowadays, it is common for financial regulators to publish lists on their official web site to make it even easier for the public to find out the standing of an entity.

Financial Regulators and Trader Protection

Some financial regulators are renowned for enforcing strict rules regarding trader protection, while others are known to be more lenient and not as eager to priorotize the safety of traders on the financial markets. Where a financial operator – such as a broker – is based and regulated can have a major impact on trader rights; both on paper and when it comes to actually having your rights enforced.

Examples of financial regulators known for maintaining a high level of trader protection

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the United Kingdom
The FCA is one of the most respected financial regulators globally. It supervises circa 58,000 firms and promotes the integrity of the UK financial system. The FCA is responsible for regulating financial firms – including both retail and wholsale – and for maintaining the integrity of the financal markets in the UK. Its strict framework of rules includes many provisions regarding trader protection and market transparency.

The FCA is a fairly new organization, as it replaced the older Financial Services Authority (FSA) in 2013. It derives its powers from the Financial Services Act 2012, which came into force on the 1^st of April, 2013. This act established a new regulatory structure consisting of the Bank of England’s Financial Policy Committee, the FCA, and the Prudential Regulation Authority. These three entities work alongside each other to set regulatory requirements for the financial sector in the UK.

The FCA operates independently of the UK Government and is financed by fees paid by the financial service industry. It is structured as a company limited by guarantee.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States
The SEC oversees securities trading in the United States, enforcing laws that protect investors from fraud and ensuring that the securities markets operate fairly. It ensures companies comply with disclosure regulations, and one of its main tasks is to prevent and clamp down on market manipulation.

The SEC has a three-part mission:

Protect investors
Maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets
Facilitate capital formation

The SEC is responsible for enforcing several laws, including the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Trust Indenture Act of 1939, the Investment Company Act of 1940, the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, and the Sarbanes–Oxley Act of 2002.

Created by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the SEC is an independent agency of the United States federal government. It was established as a reaction to the Wall Street Crash of 1929.

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)

ASIC monitors and enforces laws that regulate financial markets and financial services in Australia. It plays a key role in ensuring that businesses are honest and transparent in their dealings with consumers and investors.

ASIC is the national corporate regulator in Australia. It is responsble for regulating companies and financial services, and for enforcing applicable laws to protect Australian consumers, investors, and creditors.

Examples of legislation administered by ASIC:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001
Business Names Registration Act 2011
Corporations Act 2001
Insurance Contracts Act 1984
National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009

ASIC also administers parts of several other acts, including the Banking Act 1959, the Life Insurance Act 1995, the Retirement Savings Accounts Act 1997, the Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993, and the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993.

ASIC is an independent commission of the Australian Government and reports to the Treasurer.

When the commission was first created (by the ASC Act 1989) on the 1^st of January, 1991, it was named the Australian Securities Commission (ASC). In 1998, ASC turned into ASIC, in accordance with recommendations from the Wallis Inquiry. Today, ASIC´s scope and authority are determined by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001. Several new responsibilities have been added to ASIC over the years, including responsibility for the Australian Stock Exchange (since 2009).

Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC)
CySEC regulates financial services firms in Cyprus, a popular jurisdiction for financial firms that are active in the European Union. CySEC ensures that investment firms comply with EU directives and provides investor protections similar to those in the UK and US markets. Since Cyprus is a EU member, CySEC´s financial regulations and operations always comply with the European MiFID financial harmonization law.

CySEC is a public corporate body with the following responsibilities:

Supervising and controling the operations of the Cyprus Stock Exchange, and its listed companies, brokers, and brokerage firms.
Supervising and controlling Licensed Investment Services Companies, Collective Investment funds, investment consultants and mutual fund management companies.
Licensing investment firms (including investment consultants, brokerage firms, and brokers).
Imposing sanctions and disciplinary penalties to to brokers, brokerage firms, investment consultants, and other legal or natural persons who fall under the provisions of the Stock Market legislation.
Carrying out investigations regarding the entities that it regulates. CySEC has wide reaching powers in this respect, and is for instance permitted to enter premises and search them. CySEC is also allowed to share any findings with foreign regulators.

CySEC was established in 2001 by section 5 of the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (Establishment and Responsibilities) Law of 2001. When Cyprus joined the European Union in 2004, firms registered with CySEC got access to the European Union market. In the past, Cyprus was known as a bit of a tax haven, and it was not considered a very serious country when it came to trader protection. Today, that is no longer the case.

Over the years, CySEC has worked diligently to establish itself as a strong and reputable finance regulator with a clear trader protection ethos. In 2012, they became the first financial regulator that actually recognized and regulated binary options as financial instruments – forcing binary option brokers to comply with financial instrument legislation. In 2018, they went a step further and temporarily banned brokers from offering binary options to retail traders. In 2019, the temporary ban was exchanged for a permanent one. This change was in line with the expectations of the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA).

Examples of financial regulators known for being less stringent about trader protection

Belize International Financial Services Commission (IFSC): Although the IFSC in Belize provides some oversight for brokers, it is considered less stringent than regulators in major financial centers. Some brokers may choose Belize for its lighter regulation, which can lead to increased risks for investors.
The Vanuatu Financial Services Commission (VFSC): Vanuatu is a jurisdiction where brokers often operate with less oversight. While firms regulated by the VFSC may operate legitimately, they do so under fewer requirements, which makes them less reliable for consumer protection.
The Seychelles Financial Services Authority (FSA): The Seychelles FSA is a regulator known for its less strict requirements when it comes to trader protection. While some firms licensed by the FSA may be reputable, they are subject to lighter scrutiny, which can put investors at greater risk.

Importance of Regulation for Investors

Financial regulation is crucial for market stability and investor protection. Without strong oversight, financial markets can become rife with fraud, manipulation, and unfair practices. This can result in significant losses for retail investors and undermine trust in the financial system.

Regulation not only helps protect against bad actors but also ensures that firms maintain capital reserves to cover potential losses, reducing the risk of systemic failure. Moreover, by enforcing disclosure standards, regulators ensure that investors have access to the information they need to make informed decisions.

Financial regulators are critical in maintaining the trust and stability of financial markets. They protect investors by preventing fraud, promoting transparency, and ensuring market integrity. Investors must be cautious when choosing brokers or financial institutions, always verifying that they are regulated by a reputable authority. By selecting firms under the jurisdiction of trusted regulators, investors can significantly reduce the risk of falling victim to fraud or unethical business practices. If an issue arises, it is easier to get it resolved if the financial entity falls under the auspices of a serious financial regulator that offers conflict resultion options that are easy to use for ordinary traders and consumers.

Comments Off on What Do Financial Regulators Do?